Settlement vs. Trial: What to Expect in PA Malpractice Cases

Facing a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania can be stressful and confusing. If you’re thinking about pursuing a claim, one of your biggest questions may be whether your case will settle or go to trial. Each path has its own process, timing, and possible outcomes. Understanding the differences between settlements and trials—and what to expect from each—can help you make the right choices with your Philadelphia medical malpractice lawyer.

How Medical Malpractice Settlements Work in Pennsylvania

Most medical malpractice claims in Pennsylvania never go to trial. Instead, they end in a settlement. A settlement is an agreement between you (the injured patient) and the healthcare provider or their insurer to resolve your claim for a set amount of money. Both sides give up the right to take the case to court.

Settlements can happen at any stage—sometimes before a lawsuit is even filed, but more often after both sides have exchanged evidence and expert opinions during discovery. Your medical malpractice attorneys will work to gather strong documentation and negotiate for fair compensation based on your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future needs.

Choosing to settle can bring several benefits:

  • It usually takes less time than a trial.
  • You avoid the unpredictability of a jury decision.
  • Your claim remains private, rather than becoming public record.

However, a settlement may mean accepting less than the maximum possible amount. Your attorney will explain whether a settlement offer fairly reflects your damages and legal rights under PA law.

What Happens When a Malpractice Case Goes to Trial

When a settlement isn’t reached, your case may go to trial. In Pennsylvania, this process is detailed and can take a year or more. Trials allow both sides to present evidence, call expert witnesses, and argue their case before a judge or jury.

At trial, your medical malpractice lawyer must prove that the healthcare provider did not meet the accepted standard of care and that this failure caused your injury. The defense will argue their side and present their own experts. The jury (or judge, in some cases) decides whether malpractice occurred and, if so, how much compensation you should receive.

Trials can lead to higher awards, especially if your case is strong or the provider’s conduct was reckless. But trials are also riskier, more expensive, and take much longer than most settlements. You could win a large verdict—or receive nothing at all.

Advantages and Disadvantages: Settlement vs. Trial

Both options come with upsides and downsides. Settlements are faster, less stressful, and give you more control over the outcome. But sometimes, the other side won’t offer a fair amount, and going to trial may be your only way to pursue full compensation.

Here’s what to consider:

  • Settlements: Quicker, less costly, private, and less emotional strain. But you may need to compromise on the amount.
  • Trials: Potential for a larger award, chance to hold a provider publicly accountable, and sometimes needed if the insurer refuses a reasonable settlement. But trials are public, unpredictable, lengthy, and require appearing in court.

Your Philadelphia personal injury lawyer will help you weigh these factors based on your medical evidence, the strengths of your claim, and your personal needs.

Special Rules and Limits in Pennsylvania Malpractice Cases

Pennsylvania law has several rules affecting settlements and trials in medical malpractice cases:

  • Statute of Limitations: In most cases, you have two years from when you knew or should have known about the harm to start a claim. Some cases, such as those involving children or concealment, have exceptions.
  • Expert Certifications: To file a lawsuit, your medical malpractice attorney must certify that they have consulted with a qualified medical expert who supports your claim.
  • Damages Caps: If your claim is against a government agency, damages are capped ($250,000 for state agencies, $500,000 for local governments, with specific limits on the type of damages recoverable). Private healthcare providers do not have set caps, but punitive damages are limited.
  • Mandatory Mediation: Courts may order mediation to encourage settlement before trial.

Knowing these rules helps you and your attorney shape your strategy and set realistic expectations.

How Your Attorney Helps You Through Either Option

A skilled medical malpractice lawyer will advise you at every step—whether you’re considering settlement, going to mediation, or preparing for trial. Lawyers handle negotiations, gather evidence, explain legal procedures, and represent you in court if needed.

Most importantly, your lawyer will explain the pros and cons of every offer, help you decide what’s best for your situation, and fight for your rights under Pennsylvania law.

FAQs About Settlement vs. Trial: What to Expect in PA Malpractice Cases

How long does it take to settle a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania?
Most cases settle within several months to a year, depending on complexity and negotiations. Some cases may take longer if there are disputes about fault or the severity of the injury.

Will my medical malpractice case definitely go to trial if a settlement isn’t reached?
Not necessarily. Even after trial preparations start, cases can settle at any point—even in the middle of trial. Your Philly medical malpractice attorney will always look for the best outcome.

Are settlements or trial awards taxable in Pennsylvania?
Generally, compensation for physical injuries or medical expenses is not taxable. However, some parts of awards, like punitive damages or interest, may be taxed. Discuss details with your attorney and a tax professional.

Can I appeal if I lose my trial?
You may be able to appeal if you lose at trial, but appeals can take years and are not guaranteed to succeed. A medical malpractice lawyers can explain appeal rights and help you decide the best steps for your situation.

Other Resources About Step-by-Step Guide for Victims

Practice Areas

Get Your Case Evaluation Today for FREE

(215) 227-2727

EMAIL US

TOLL FREE:
(866)-907-2231

NO RECOVERY, NO FEE. GUARANTEED.

Our record of success

Over $500 Million Recovered

$80 Million

Transvaginal mesh jury verdict

$20 Million

Birth INJURY CAUSING BRAIN DAMAGE

$6.75 Million

ATV Accident CAUSING BRAIN DAMAGE

View all Case Results

From our Clients

See more testimonials

I would not have been able to achieve the results and reach the settlement that I was awarded without the legal representation of My Philly Lawyer. Thank you Dean and Frank and your entire team.

Darnell B

My Philly Lawyer represented me for an auto accident. The entire process was a pleasure. I was more than satisfied with the outcome. During a normally stressful time, I was put at ease by the entire staff at My Philly Lawyer and I won’t hesitate to have them represent me again.

Craig R.

MyPhillyLawyer absolutely the best in Philadelphia. Dean, Joshua and Deana are the best and they will get you the results you deserve! I’m so grateful and appreciative for their assistance and support!

Hass M.

My experience with MyPhilly lawyer has been wonderful. There is nothing better than feeling like the team is on your side. The staff has always taken my calls , no matter what time. I’m extremely grateful for MyPhilly lawyer.

Corynna M.

I highly recommend Dean Weitzman. He was empathetic and listened carefully to the impact the accident had upon my physical and mental health. I believe he negotiated the very best settlement he could have gotten.

Christina R.

Their team is absolutely amazing and is there to help you every step of the way. I would highly recommend them, they know there stuff and will do what it takes to help their clients.

Brittany M.