The Role of the Certificate of Merit in Pennsylvania Malpractice Claims

If you’re thinking about filing a medical malpractice lawsuit in Pennsylvania, you’ll quickly hear about something called the “certificate of merit.” This important document is a required part of starting most malpractice cases. Understanding what it is, why it matters, and how it affects your claim is essential for anyone harmed by medical negligence in Philadelphia or anywhere in the Commonwealth.

What Is a Certificate of Merit in a Malpractice Case?

A certificate of merit is a legal filing your attorney must submit when starting a medical malpractice lawsuit in Pennsylvania. The main purpose is to show the court that a qualified medical expert has reviewed your case and believes there is a reasonable basis to claim that a healthcare provider deviated from the accepted standard of care. This rule helps prevent baseless lawsuits and ensures only claims with genuine merit move forward.

The certificate must be filed with (or soon after) your complaint. It must confirm that, after a review of the facts and medical records, an expert supports your claim. If the certificate isn’t filed on time, the court can dismiss your case. This is why it’s so important to work with a knowledgeable Philadelphia medical malpractice lawyer who understands the process.

Why Is a Certificate of Merit Required for Medical Malpractice Lawsuits?

Pennsylvania law requires a certificate of merit to stop frivolous lawsuits from clogging the courts. Medical cases are complex and often hinge on opinions from trained professionals. The certificate of merit guarantees that before you go to court, a qualified medical expert has found evidence of possible negligence by the healthcare provider.

Pennsylvania’s laws (specifically, Article VIII-A, Section 821-A and 823-A of the Health Care Services Malpractice Act) lay out how and when the certificate must be filed. The law expects that your attorney has a report from a qualified expert that explains the standard of care and how it was breached. If your lawyer files a case without the required certificate, the court can sanction your attorney and even dismiss the lawsuit. That’s why experienced medical malpractice attorneys take this requirement seriously.

Who Can Provide the Expert Opinion for a Certificate of Merit?

Only a qualified expert, usually a physician in the same or similar field as the provider being sued, can provide the opinion needed for a certificate of merit. Pennsylvania law says the expert must review the facts, medical records, and other evidence before making a determination. The expert should have active experience in the area of medicine involved in the claim.

For example, if your malpractice case involves a surgical error, the expert should be a surgeon who regularly performs similar procedures. If your case is about a misdiagnosis by a family doctor, the expert should be a primary care physician or internist. A medical malpractice attorney will help find the right expert to meet state standards.

Are There Exceptions to the Certificate of Merit Requirement?

There are a few exceptions. Pennsylvania law allows your attorney to delay the certificate of merit in specific situations, such as:

  • When you have less than 120 days before the statute of limitations expires when first contacting an attorney.
  • When you do not have medical records needed to complete the review, despite making a proper request.
  • When discovery is needed to determine if malpractice occurred.
  • When expert testimony isn’t needed because the mistake is obvious (such as leaving a surgical sponge inside a patient).

In these cases, your attorney may proceed without the certificate, but must submit it within 90 days after the triggering event (such as getting the records or completing discovery). A Philly medical malpractice attorney can help determine if an exception applies to your case.

What Happens If the Certificate of Merit Is Not Filed or Is Defective?

Failing to file a valid certificate of merit can seriously harm your case. Pennsylvania courts take this requirement seriously. If the certificate is missing or doesn’t meet legal standards, the court can strike your complaint and dismiss your lawsuit. In some cases, the court may allow you to fix the error if you act quickly and have a good reason.

Additionally, if an attorney knowingly files a certificate without an expert review, or misleads the court, there can be disciplinary actions and financial penalties. This underscores the need to have a medical malpractice lawyer with experience handling these claims.

FAQs About the Role of the Certificate of Merit in Pennsylvania Malpractice Claims

Why does Pennsylvania require a certificate of merit in malpractice cases?
The certificate of merit is required to ensure that only claims supported by a qualified expert move forward. It keeps weak or unfounded cases out of court, saving time and resources for everyone involved.

What information does an expert need to provide for the certificate of merit?
The expert must review your medical records and the facts of your case. They must state that there is a reasonable basis to believe the healthcare provider failed to meet the standard of care. This review is summarized in the expert’s report, which your attorney certifies to the court.

Can I still file a claim if my case falls under an exception?
Yes, you can file a claim under certain exceptions, such as when you lack medical records or need discovery before an expert can make a determination. However, you must still file the certificate of merit as soon as the exception no longer applies. A medical malpractice lawyer can help you meet all deadlines.

How do I make sure my certificate of merit is valid?
Work with a medical malpractice lawyer who handles these cases regularly. They’ll ensure the expert is qualified, the review is complete, and all court rules are followed so your malpractice lawsuit has the strongest possible start.

Other Resources About Understanding Medical Malpractice Law in Pennsylvania

Practice Areas

Get Your Case Evaluation Today for FREE

(215) 227-2727

EMAIL US

TOLL FREE:
(866)-907-2231

NO RECOVERY, NO FEE. GUARANTEED.

Our record of success

Over $500 Million Recovered

$80 Million

Transvaginal mesh jury verdict

$20 Million

Birth INJURY CAUSING BRAIN DAMAGE

$6.75 Million

ATV Accident CAUSING BRAIN DAMAGE

View all Case Results

From our Clients

See more testimonials

I would not have been able to achieve the results and reach the settlement that I was awarded without the legal representation of My Philly Lawyer. Thank you Dean and Frank and your entire team.

Darnell B

My Philly Lawyer represented me for an auto accident. The entire process was a pleasure. I was more than satisfied with the outcome. During a normally stressful time, I was put at ease by the entire staff at My Philly Lawyer and I won’t hesitate to have them represent me again.

Craig R.

MyPhillyLawyer absolutely the best in Philadelphia. Dean, Joshua and Deana are the best and they will get you the results you deserve! I’m so grateful and appreciative for their assistance and support!

Hass M.

My experience with MyPhilly lawyer has been wonderful. There is nothing better than feeling like the team is on your side. The staff has always taken my calls , no matter what time. I’m extremely grateful for MyPhilly lawyer.

Corynna M.

I highly recommend Dean Weitzman. He was empathetic and listened carefully to the impact the accident had upon my physical and mental health. I believe he negotiated the very best settlement he could have gotten.

Christina R.

Their team is absolutely amazing and is there to help you every step of the way. I would highly recommend them, they know there stuff and will do what it takes to help their clients.

Brittany M.