Third-Party Claims: When Someone Else Is at Fault

Work injuries can happen in an instant, changing your life and your ability to provide for your family. Many people know about workers’ compensation, but what if your work injury was caused by someone who isn’t your employer or a coworker? In Philadelphia, you might have the right to file a third-party claim when another person or company is to blame for your workplace injury. These cases can be complicated, so having the right work injury lawyer is important. Let’s walk through how third-party claims work, who can be held responsible, and why legal help matters.

Understanding Third-Party Claims After a Work Injury

Most people think that if you’re hurt at work, your only option is workers’ compensation. While workers’ comp provides medical coverage and wage loss, it doesn’t always cover all your losses. It also limits your ability to sue your employer. But what if someone outside your company caused the accident? That’s where a third-party claim comes in.

A third-party claim is a legal action against someone other than your employer or coworker who played a role in your injury. For example, if a delivery driver is hurt because another motorist ran a red light, the at-fault driver can be sued. Or, if faulty equipment from a manufacturer causes harm, that company could be responsible. Third-party claims allow you to seek damages that go beyond what workers’ compensation offers, such as pain and suffering, lost future earnings, and more.

Philadelphia law lets injured workers hold careless third parties accountable. However, making these claims isn’t always straightforward. You’ll need an experienced Philly work injury lawyer to help you understand your rights and build a strong case.

Common Third Parties Who May Be Liable for Work Injuries

Not every work injury involves only your employer. There are many situations where someone else’s actions or negligence creates danger. Here are some common examples of third parties who can be liable:

• Drivers: Car crashes on the job are frequent. If you drive as part of your work and another driver’s carelessness causes an accident, you can file a third-party lawsuit against them.
• Contractors and Subcontractors: Construction sites often involve several companies working together. If a worker from another company causes your injury, or their equipment is unsafe, they can be sued.
• Property Owners: If you’re hurt because of unsafe conditions at a job site owned by someone other than your employer, you can hold the owner responsible.
• Product Manufacturers: Defective machines, tools, or safety gear can cause serious harm. The company that designed, made, or sold the faulty product may be liable.
• Maintenance Companies: If your injury happened because a maintenance company failed to properly repair or inspect equipment, they can also be held accountable.

Each scenario requires proof that the third party was careless or violated safety laws. A skilled workers’ compensation lawyer can help identify who might be to blame and what evidence you’ll need.

How Third-Party Claims Work with Workers’ Compensation

Many injured workers wonder if they can get both workers’ compensation and file a lawsuit. In Philadelphia and across Pennsylvania, the answer is yes. You can receive workers’ compensation benefits and still file a claim against a third party who caused your injury.

Workers’ compensation covers your medical care and partial lost wages regardless of who was at fault. But these benefits often don’t cover everything, such as pain and suffering or the full amount of lost future income. That’s why pursuing a third-party claim can be so important. If you win or settle your case, you may have to pay back some of your workers’ comp benefits out of your recovery. This process is called subrogation. A work injury lawyer can make sure this process is handled correctly, so you don’t lose out on money you deserve.

It’s important to act quickly. Pennsylvania law sets time limits for filing third-party lawsuits, and waiting too long could mean losing your right to sue. Working with an attorney who understands both workers’ comp and personal injury law ensures that your case stays on track.

Why You Need a Lawyer for a Third-Party Work Injury Claim

Filing a third-party claim is not the same as a regular workers’ compensation claim. You have to prove that the other party was negligent or broke a law that led to your injury. This can involve gathering evidence, interviewing witnesses, and working with experts to show how the accident happened.

Insurance companies for third parties fight hard to avoid paying. They might blame you, argue the injury isn’t serious, or delay your claim. Having a workers’ compensation attorney in your corner makes all the difference. Your lawyer can:

• Investigate your accident and collect vital evidence
• Handle paperwork and court filings on your behalf
• Negotiate with insurance companies for a fair settlement
• Take your case to trial if the other side won’t pay what’s fair
• Protect your rights during the workers’ comp subrogation process

A lawyer can also help you understand how much your case might be worth and what damages you can claim. If you’re unsure where to start, contact a Philadelphia workers’ compensation attorney who can guide you every step of the way.

Real-Life Examples of Third-Party Work Injury Claims

Seeing real situations can make the process clearer. Here are some common examples of third-party work injury claims in Philadelphia:

• Delivery Driver Accident: Carla delivers packages in Center City. Another driver, distracted by a phone, rear-ends her van. Carla suffers a back injury. She can file for workers’ compensation with her employer and sue the at-fault driver for full damages.
• Construction Site Fall: Mike, a roofer, trips over debris left behind by a different crew. The debris wasn’t marked or removed. He breaks his leg. Mike’s claim can target the subcontractor responsible for site cleanup, on top of his own employer’s workers’ comp coverage.
• Machinery Malfunction: Sara works at a printing plant. A press jams and her hand is crushed. Investigation reveals a defect in the machine’s guard, and the manufacturer had issued a recall. Sara’s third-party claim can be against the manufacturer.
• Unsafe Building Conditions: Tom, a building inspector, slips on an icy walkway that the property management failed to salt. He fractures his wrist. He can file a claim against the property owner’s insurance in addition to workers’ comp.

Each of these cases highlights why it’s so important to look beyond just workers’ comp after a work injury. A work injury lawyer can examine your case and see if a third-party claim might get you the compensation you truly need.

---

FAQs About Third-Party Claims

Can I file a third-party claim if I already get workers’ comp?

Yes, you can. Pennsylvania law lets you collect workers’ comp benefits and still sue a third party if they caused your injury. Your lawyer can help you handle both claims at the same time.

What damages can I recover in a third-party claim that I can’t get from workers’ comp?

Third-party claims can include pain and suffering, full lost wages, loss of future earning capacity, and sometimes punitive damages. Workers’ comp only covers medical care and a portion of your lost wages.

How long do I have to file a third-party lawsuit after a work injury?

In most cases, you have two years from the date of injury to file a third-party claim in Pennsylvania. Don’t wait, as missing this deadline can bar your claim.

Who pays if I win a third-party work injury lawsuit?

The at-fault party’s insurance usually pays your settlement or verdict. This could be a driver’s auto insurance, a property owner’s liability policy, or a manufacturer’s insurer, depending on your case.

For more information or to discuss your case, contact a Philadelphia personal injury lawyer at MyPhillyLawyer today.

Other Injury Situations & Scenarios

• Healthcare Worker Injuries: Common Risks and Claims
• Construction Site Injuries: Unique Challenges and Solutions
• Injured During a Work-Related Car Accident: What Next?
• Injuries While Working Remotely or Off-Site
• Third-Party Claims: When Someone Else Is at Fault